Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    62
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

5 out of 5 based on 72 ratings.
52 user reviews.
Includes 10 Rate My Agent reviews
Property

Tricia was such a great resource for us when buying our first home. She educated us on anything that we might overlook and was a great listener. She also has a ton of contacts for contractors. I will be recommending her to any friends I know looking to purchase.

Kyle Montler
Apr 02, 2026
Property

We had a great experience working with Tricia for our first home purchase! As first-time buyers, we had a lot of questions (some pretty small and random), and she was always patient, responsive, and happy to help. She made the whole process feel much less overwhelming and guided us through every ste... Read More

The Kempers
Mar 09, 2026
Property

Tricia patiently helped our sone navigate a first purchase over several seasons. She understood his budget and preferences. Most helpfully she educated him about the home buying process and patiently answered many questions. Great experience.

Dave
Mar 07, 2026
Property

Tricia is hands-down the most helpful and dedicated agent I’ve worked with. She didn't just list my property; she guided me through the entire prep process, including finding reliable help to get the condo listing-ready. Her social media marketing is brilliant and reached so many potential buyers.... Read More

Dr. Karen Hall
Jan 29, 2026
Property

We cannot say enough good things about Tricia. From start to finish, she was patient, attentive, and genuinely had our best interests in mind. As first-time homebuyers, we had a lot of questions, and Tricia was more than just a realtor—she felt like a counselor and trusted advisor. She consistentl... Read More

Dylan W.
Jan 26, 2026
Property

We looked for a house for around two years and never once felt rushed. She consistently gave thoughtful, helpful feedback on homes—things that, as first-time homeowners, we wouldn’t have known to look for. She truly had our best interests in mind, which is so important with such a big purchase. ... Read More

Kathleen Wright
Jan 13, 2026
Property

Our experience with Tricia couldn’t have been better! Once she learned our list of what we were looking for, she worked hard to find properties that had most of our interests. She was always patient and kind and available. She seemed as happy for us with the house we chose as we were. I would r... Read More

Mark A. Linstedt
Dec 08, 2025
Property

Tricia was excellent to work with! She provided guidance when needed and a sounding board as we navigated a major move from PA to Ohio! We decided to build a house in an Epcon Community and since we were far away during the building process, Tricia made a point of stopping by the house to check prog... Read More

Pam Linstedt
Nov 25, 2025
Property

We have worked with Tricia twice now. Both times she helped us tremendously in the buying process- helping us to consider things we may have missed, and ensuring we were able to put our best foot forward in a competitive market. When we needed to sell our house, she went above and beyond getting it ... Read More

Danny M.
Oct 18, 2025
Property

Tricia is amazing to work with! She is professional, trustworthy, kind and an expert in her field. We felt confident every step of the home buying process because of Tricia’s guidance and support. We recommend her to everyone!

Mary Meyung
Oct 17, 2025

Tricia was absolutely wonderful! Knowing we were two hours away, she utilized our time, and hers, very efficiently and did not waste one moment in helping us find our new home. She really went above and beyond, learning about our lives and situation and really understanding what we were looking for. We loved her immediately!!

"Parker Family Trust of January 11, 2000" Melisa K. Parker, Trustee
Jun 23, 2025

Tricia Koehler is an outstanding realtor! We were referred by a friend who gave a ringing endorsement and so do we! She made us feel like we the most important client she had and was always available to talk, text or meetup. And coming into town from another part of the state we had LOTS of questions! Tricia’s knowledge of the market was invaluable, especially since it is so different from the one we came from. We highly, highly recommend her as your realtor!

"Parker Family Trust of January 11, 2000" Thomas M. Parker, Trustee
Jun 22, 2025

Tricia was amazing to work with! We felt so cared for every step of the way through buying our new home and selling our old. I would recommend Tricia to anyone!

Andrea Bowers
Jun 09, 2025

Such a phenomenal experience working with Tricia in purchasing my FIRST HOME. Positive, encouraging attitude throughout, offers great counsel, readily available, knowledgeable answers to questions -- would wholeheartedly recommend! This is the realtor experience you are looking for! THANK YOU TRICIA!

Jason Holmes | Home Buyer
Jun 09, 2025

Tricia was excellent to work with! She is professional, personable and timely. We would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home!

Elijah Bowers
Jun 08, 2025

Tricia did a fantastic job through the entire process of selling our house! She is professional and very knowledgeable. We hit a few bumps along the way and she handled them efficiently with confidence. We would highly recommend Tricia to anyone who is looking for a outstanding realtor to get the job done!

Kathleen F. Cripe
Jun 03, 2025

Working with Tricia Koehler was great!

Ashot Nalbandyan
May 07, 2025

We had a fantastic experience working with Tricia! When our friends referred her and mentioned they became friends during the house-buying process, we honestly found it hard to believe, but now we completely understand. Throughout the entire journey, she was knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely supportive. Not only did she help us find the perfect home, but we also feel like we've gained a friend in the process. We're so grateful and would recommend her without hesitation to anyone looking for a truly exceptional realtor!

Ashot Nalbandyan | Home Buyer
May 02, 2025

highly would suggest!!

Sean Bergeron
Mar 01, 2025

Tricia as always was amazing to work with. She made the process of buying a new home and selling our current home very easy!

Scott Madsen
Dec 24, 2024

We LOVE Tricia!!! The best of the best. She advocates for you, is so knowledgeable, and goes above and beyond.

Brian Do
Nov 07, 2024

Tricia was amazing! We’ve been considering a move on and off for about two years. Even with our sporadic search, she was always prompt and helpful when we had questions and wanted to see properties and she kept us in the loop when our search stalled. When we finally spotted THE house, she was ready to take us through it at a moment’s notice. When we decided to submit an offer, she made great suggestions on how to make it competitive. She shepherded us through every step of the buying process with a positive attitude, enthusiasm, and kindness.

Amy Bethune
Oct 24, 2024

We are so thankful to have had Tricia in our corner in the buying and selling process! We were on quite the rollercoaster as we sold our home in Hilliard and purchased in Dublin and Tricia was steady and supportive through it all. She really listens to her clients to understand what they’re looking for in their home and makes sure not to rush the process until they find the exact home that fits their needs. We would recommend Tricia to anyone looking to buy or sell a house in Columbus - she is a wealth of knowledge!

Naomi Koehler
Sep 07, 2024

Tricia went above and beyond to ensure we felt confident, comfortable, and knowledgeable throughout the entire house buying process. She made it fun and provided incredible insights. She was encouraging and always seemed to know what we needed to hear in a particular moment. Tricia clearly had our best interest at heart and navigated tough situations with poise and grace. We’d recommend Tricia to anyone and everyone! We already have!

Elizabeth C Linstedt
Aug 23, 2024

Tricia was absolutely amazing! This has been a long journey to find the specific property and Tricia's support was unwavering! Her honesty and positive approach made the experience unbelievable. Frankly we are going to miss touring houses with her. Her assistance in understanding what we need to do to sell our current property was invaluable. Tricia made everything easy. I definitely will be recommending her to friends and colleges looking for a home, or wanting to sell. I seriously can't say enough good things about her and our experience!

Rob Kluz
Jul 04, 2024

Tricia is the best- got top dollar for our home and bought ours at the best value! Tricia cares for her clients and goes above and beyond to serve them!

Steve Thompson
Jun 06, 2024

Tricia went above and beyond to help us as both buyers and sellers in an extremely competitive market. Her market analysis, guidance and marketing strategies were top notch. She made the process seamless from beginning to end in what could have been a very stressful time. We could not recommend Tricia more!

Carrie Thompson
May 22, 2024

Tricia and Cutler Realty did a wonderful job marketing and selling my home. Tricia was very professional and helpful throughout the sale of my current home and the purchase of my new build. I felt I had a true advocate along side me. I highly recommend Tricia Kohler and Cutler Realty.

Sherri J. Hughes
May 08, 2024

This is our 5th home and the best experience we’ve had.

Dale Kemper
Mar 15, 2024

Tricia was amazing! Efficient, helpful, priced the house perfectly to get lots of traffic through (4 open houses, 39 showings and 7 offers) and get a fantastic price for our home. She led us through the whole process professionally and respectfully and all her advice really paid off. Her connections were extremely helpful as far as professional photography, staging, etc. Tricia made it easy and we are so grateful! I have already recommended her to several people and talked her up to anyone asking about our home sale!

Ellen Kemper
Mar 13, 2024

Tricia went above and beyond every step of this process. We were moving in from out of state and she called service people on our behalf to get estimates for work we needed done on our home before we even arrived. We would work with her again in a heartbeat!

Nicole Tebbano
Mar 06, 2024

Tricia did a wonderful job from start to finish. She is knowledgeable, thorough and efficient. Would highly recommend he to anyone who is looking to make a real estate transaction.

Katy Cripe
Jan 20, 2024

Tricia went above and beyond to make every step up the process understandable and smooth and helped get us into our dream home!

Daniel Blust
Nov 27, 2023

Tricia was super helpful & available to us. She knew what we were looking for in a house & did everything in her power to get us there! We love Tricia!!!

Katharina M Allgor
Nov 24, 2023

We’ve been working with Tricia for 2.5 years now searching for our home. She was always honest, helpful, and supportive. That is a long time to be looking and she never gave up or lost hope for us. We are so so thankful to have found our home, and for all of the help Tricia was to us!

Grace Blust
Nov 22, 2023

Tricia is such a wonderful professional! She’s not only a Realtor but a great advisor in all things regarding home buying. Even regarding personal matters, she exhibits a wisdom which is beneficial for everyone to hear!

Adrian Nicholas Cole
Nov 07, 2023

We’re happy

George Hazlett (or Nominee)
Oct 05, 2023

I would highly recommend Tricia to anyone considering buying or selling. She is incredibly professional yet personable and realizes that buying and selling are stressful times for the client. Her marketing skills in selling our home were impressive, resulting in us receiving multiple bids and a much higher offer over asking price. She was available to us 7 days a week at anytime. Can’t say enough positive things!

Jerome Robison
Sep 18, 2023

Tricia is very positive, encouraging and promptly makes herself available by phone and text. We have enjoyed our home purchase experience with her and anticipate a continuing friendship.

Phyllis J. Smouse
Apr 26, 2023

Tricia was always available to assist us in the process. She is particularly good at promptly responding to calls and texts. Tricia showed us properties that were appropriate for our needs. She was an effective listener and gave her opinion as requested. We would highly recommend Tricia as an agent. We appreciate that Tricia was always thinking ahead and genuinely had our interest at heart.

Robert G. Smouse
Apr 26, 2023

Tricia was wonderful! She gave us excellent advice on selling our house from staging to remedies. She was incredibly patient o our housing hunt and knowledgeable about the area. She was extremely prompt with everything. We are so pleased to have worked with her!

Zachary D Oglevee
Nov 09, 2022

Tricia was a fantastic resource for us as first-time home buyers. She walked us though every step of the way so we could feel confident in our purchase.

Rebecca Joines
Oct 28, 2022

Tricia has gone to bat for my wife and me many times during the build process. We are doing our build while living out of state and she has made herself available to drive us to and from vendors, to and from the airport and to our build site. She has been an amazing liaison. Her extraordinary knowledge of the local real estate market has been a godsend.

Robert S. Schuster
Aug 10, 2022

Tricia was generous with her time and patient while we learned the area and helped us to find the property that best suited us. She’s also just a very nice, thoughtful person.

Verna Hazlett
Aug 08, 2022

See “other comments”

George Hazlett
Aug 07, 2022

We knew nothing of the area and Tricia was extremely patient with us. No hard sell.

Verna Hazlett
Jul 26, 2022

Very hard working and patient

George Hazlett
Jul 26, 2022

Having Tricia handle both purchase and sale of my properties helped with coordination between the two. I would not hesitate to use Tricia for any future real estate needs.

Miriam Y. Clingman
Jun 25, 2022

Tricia is the BEST! She made buying and selling a house so so easy. She started off as a realtor and ended as our friend, we cant say enough good things about her. She’s reliable, knowledgeable, efficient, kind, patient and so much more. If we ever need to sell/ buy again she will be the first person I call! best realtor ever :)

Madison Roth
Jun 16, 2022

As first time homebuyers, my husband and I didn’t know if it would be possible for us to find our home. Tricia made the process as easy and seamless as possible. Couldn’t be happier with our new home!

Alexandra Thompson
May 12, 2022

Tricia did a great job keeping me informed throughout the buying and selling process and always replied to my texts quickly. Tricia also is so well organized and pays attention to the little details, keeping the process running smoothly . I wouldn't hesitate to use Tricia again in my next real estate transaction.

Miriam Y Clingman, Trustee
Apr 18, 2022

Tricia went so far above and beyond helping my family make repairs and get the most value from our house. She is truly one of a kind in the real estate business.

James Khoury TTE
Mar 01, 2022

Tricia is very personable and helpful. She is always timely in her responses! She is wonderful to work with!

Stephanie G Lemyre
Feb 12, 2022

Very responsive! Helpful in every way. Very cheerful!

Stephanie G. Lemyre
Dec 28, 2021

Tricia is the best to work with! We felt comfortable and confident during our home buying and selling experience with her!

Charles Anthony Kabealo
Dec 15, 2021

We are so thankful for Tricia‘s guidance and support and availability during this process. We love our new home!

Tracy Lynn Kabealo
Dec 10, 2021

We worked with Tricia when purchasing our first home. She helped us understand the ins and outs of home buying and was happy to answer all our questions. The market was flooded with buyers and crazy offers, and she provided us with support and advice through the whole process. Through those six months, she stayed positive even when we were not! She checked in with us regularly, quickly responded to us, and showed us a ton of houses. She talked us through offer letters and, once we got our house, negotiated the contract so we ended up with everything we wanted. We are so thankful for the time Tricia took to get us into our home, and we would recommend her to anyone in the market for a house!

Abigail King
Oct 27, 2021

Mrs. Koehler is knowledgeable and helpful and goes the extra mile for her clients.

Frank Scipione
Oct 12, 2021

NA

Terri Petersen
Sep 21, 2021

Tricia is the best

Eric Fouche
Sep 18, 2021

x

Sarah Audet
Jul 22, 2021

.

David Audet
Jul 19, 2021

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel